Evaluation

Question One: In what ways does your media product use, develop or challenge forms and conventions of real media products?


1.       When we set out to create ‘The Lost Ones’ we by no means wanted to create a conventional thriller. We felt the genre of psychological action had very much been dominated by Hollywood in recent years, so we felt an independent and fresh take on the genre was much needed. Therefore, we set out to challenge some of the forms and conventions of typical media products.

One of the ways that we challenged conventions of media products was through the addition of cut scenes to the film. This was something inspired by Oliver Stone’s 1994 film Natural Born Killers (NBK) in which cut scenes, unrelated to the narrative of the film are displayed throughout dealing with America’s obsession with fame, crime and the media. In NBK advertisements for Coca-cola are frequently displayed, along with scenes of graphic violence (Fig1a & 1b). It was the latter that inspired some of our cut-scene’s, using themes of destruction (like nuclear explosions and riots – Fig2) to show the highly unstable and fragile state of the male protagonists mind. We felt that many major film companies would steer away from using a device like destructive cut scenes, for fear that it might distract more passive viewers from the narrative of the story-line, but as we decided to market our film at an audience who consume media more actively, we felt it would not be too much of an issue to break this convention. 


Fig 2 (Nuclear cut scene in The Lost Ones)
Fig 1a (Natural Born Killers violence cut scene)









Another typical convention of films is the use of Vladamir Propp’s character theory. Propp suggested that every typical narrative followed a similar narrative arc, based on folk fairy tales, hinting that all films must follow a distinct path and involve distinct characters (see Abit about Vladamir Propp and why he’s irrelevant). We chose to break this convention, once again because we didn’t really want to create a typical film for passive viewers. We also felt that due to the limitations of time (the film had to be only 5 minutes in length), that we would struggle to fit Propp’s narrative theory in its entirety successfully into our project.

We also broke some typical conventions with relation the character development. We chose to never reveal the identity of the male protagonist, leaving him completely anonymous. Typical Hollywood films word keep away from this approach, as they want the viewer to relate to the character and know everything about them, however we felt the anonymity approach worked well as it suggested that the male character’s situation could easily be applied to anyone. This anonymous approach was inspired by the Cormac McCarthy novel The Road in which both protagonists remain anonymous throughout.
Fig 1b (Natural Born Killers depiction of the media.)
Although we did try wherever possible to break conventions of previous media projects, it was inevitable that we would have to incorporate some of the typical forms of media products. Whilst I was writing the script of ‘The Lost Ones’, I made sure to include several metaphorical devises, many of which had been inspired by major films with major budgets. An example of this was the use of colour symbolism, a feature definitely prominent in many successful films. For example we used bright blues and greens to represent happiness, innocence and nature, as well as using dull greys and dark blues to represent misery and torment. We also chose to incorporate many features that we had seen in M. Night Shyamalan’s The Sixth Sense, mainly the lack of interaction between the “ghost” character and the rest of the world. An example of this from The Sixth Sense is when Bruce Willis (who does not realize that he is actually dead) tries to pick up the bill for a meal, but his wife intervenes, not allowing him to move the physical object. We tried to accomplish something similar in our project, making sure that Violet never interacted with the world around her, for instance unlike the male protagonist she never uses an iPod, picks up paper etc.

Our project also follows the typical film conventions suggested by Tzvetan Todorov.  Todorov suggested that all narratives’ follow a similar structure: Equilibrium, Disruption, Disruption Fixed. This is definitely true in our work. Our narrative (although not all of it is shown in the project) states that the male protagonist is engaged to Violet (Equilibrium), who then dies in an accident (Disruption). The protagonist then remembers her through a sequence of visual illusions, before letting her memory finally go (Disruption fixed). Although Todorov’s theory is not depicted entirely in the film, it is certainly implied.

We also used colour association in the film, (typical of most films) to help illustrate emotions and mind-frames. For example, at the start of the film we used blue filters, with played down black and white mid-tones to create a dull and grainy feel. We felt that this helped reflect the protagonist’s disturbed and lonely state of mind without Violet in his life. When the protagonist was imagining Violet, the colours become substantially brighter, with bright blues reflecting how he is at peace with his memories, and also suggest that he is at one and isolated with his memories, almost as if he is submerge under water.


Full details of artistic and creative devises in The Lost Ones can be found by listening to the audio podcast.





Question Two: How effective is the combination of your main product and ancillary texts?



Fig 3 (Sammy CCTV in The Lost Ones)
Fig 4 (The Review)
Fig 5 (Poster)
1.       Personally, I feel that the combination of our main project and ancillary texts works  very well, and each individual piece of work compliments the others nicely. I think this  is the case because after creating the film, we established a theme that ran strongly in the film, and made sure that we applied this theme efficiently to both of the ancillary texts. The theme that we developed followed the blue CCTV cut scenes featured in the film (Fig 3.) We felt that these still frames of Violet, isolated on a monitor helped reflect the bleak and intimidating nature of the film, and also nicely hinted at the twist ending, suggesting that the male protagonist is reliving his past life with Violet, as if he is watching it back on a CCTV monitor. We made sure that this blue CCTV theme was implemented in both the review (Fig 4.)  and the poster (Fig 5.)  completing an advertising campaign that worked together efficiently. We also felt that the use of the CCTV style imaging, definitely added intrigue to the film, possibly causing increased buzz around the film. This was definitely suggested by our audience research, which the average rating of our poster 5/5 for effectiveness. It could however be suggested that one major flaw in the design of our poster was that it was too cryptic and didn’t explain to a viewer at first glance what the film is actually about, however I think due to the nature of our film project it would have been inappropriate to have given much of the plot away, as it takes away from the cryptic nature of the movie. All in all, I think the film and the ancillary texts complement each other effectively and well.







Question Three: What have you learned from your audience feedback?



1.       I have been very happy with the audience feedback we have received so far. We asked the Year 12 Media Studies class at our school to give us their opinions on the film, rating different criteria on a scale from 1-5 (5 being top, 1 being bottom).  Full details of the audience feedback can be found here, but to summarize, most of the ratings averaged at 4/5 which we were very pleased with. This successful feedback proved to us that we had successfully made a film that was appealing to our main target audience (active teenage viewers).  One of the areas that was less successful was the overall clarity of the narrative, however I believe we managed to rectify this by re-recording the vocals on the film. The clearer dialogue made the narrative easier to understand and added clarity to the film.

We also posted the video on YouTube, and submitted it to a worldwide audience. Some of the viewers rated the film, and at the time of writing the clip has received 2/3 positive feedback and 1/3 negative. This suggests that the film does not work well with a mass audience, however this is not to concerning for us as from the start of the project we have wanted to appeal to a niche audience, which from our specific target audience screening we have learned that we have done successfully.


Question Four: How did you use new media technologies in the construction and research, planning and evaluation stages?

1.       We used many professional technologies in the creation of our media product. For the construction of the film, we used an Olympus Hybrid camera that shot in 720p high definition. We chose to use a HD camera, as it is unusual today to see a film created in anything less than 720p, and we wanted our final film to looks as professional as possible. When we started editing,  w e used two main software packages to edit the movie, Sony Vegas and Adobe Premiere Pro. We started working with Premiere at the start of the year, as we had used it for our AS level project and already knew a lot about its layout and design, however once we got a minute into the film, it started to show up severe problems. The video preview would begin to lag, and the programme would shut down up frequently every lesson, losing any unsaved work. After a long time, trying to get Premiere to run efficiently, we changed to Sony Vegas, and started editing the film again. We found Vegas to be a lot more streamlined and easy to use, however some of the effects that we managed to achieve in Premiere were unavailable. We also used a Tascam DR-05 digital recorder to re-record some of the dialogue that had become lost due to background noise when filming. This recorder proved to work very well, creating substantially better quality audio than the cameras in-built microphone.

For the ancillary tasks, we used two main pieces of Adobe software, Photoshop and Illustrator. We created the bulk of the poster and the review in Illustrator and used Photoshop primarily to make slight tweaks to photos, or to crop images down (a tool that is not included in Illustrator). It took us quite a while to learn these image manipulation packages as we had never used anything like it before, however after a few hours, we begin to find the user interface fairly simple and easy to use.

In the research phase, I used Xbox applications Netflix and Lovefilm as one of my main sources of research material. I used this streaming service to gain access to short films (see review of Cashback(2004)  that I then reviewed and took inspiration from. I also used YouTube channel FutureShorts and BBC website BBC Film Network to watch short films, many of which influenced The Lost Ones.

In the evaluation process, we used Blogger as a catalyst to record what we had done, what we were doing and what research we had done. I personally found Blogger particularly nice to use, especially when the introduced the Beta update that made the site easier to navigate. When we wanted to share files (like storyboards etc.) we used Cloud storage site Microsoft Skydrive, and just posted a link on our blog. We also used YouTube to share video files as we found Blogger’s inbuilt video streaming feature to be impractical and harder to access.


Full 30 minute evaluation Podcast with Six String Studio available here.

No comments:

Post a Comment